The best dog food isn't always the most expensiveWhy it matters
pet reviews
Retailer head-to-head

Pet Circle vs Petstock

A fair, score-by-score comparison of Pet Circle and Petstock — pricing, range, delivery and subscription value — for Australian dog owners.

Reviewed by the PetReviews editorial team

Independent scoring · Updated June 2026 · Not veterinary advice

Pet Circle delivery
Higher overall · cheaper basket

Pet Circle

Online pet store

A polished online-only retailer with a deep premium catalogue — but the everyday prices aren't always the bargain the slick site implies. Its premium positioning and heavy push of own-label ranges (Providore, The Nosh Project) mean you can often beat its per-kg price on mainstream lines elsewhere, including at Petbarn with member pricing or Repeat Delivery.

Shoppers who want a deep online premium catalogueAutoship on premium diets

Sample basket

$0

Read review →
Petstock delivery

Petstock

Online pet store

A big-box chain that lands middle-of-the-pack on almost everything. The range and vet support are fine, but it's narrower and pricier than Petbarn on most lines, and there's no category where it clearly wins. Everyday pricing leans high, so you're reliant on catching a sale or loyalty price to get value.

Shoppers near a store who want in-house vet services

Sample basket

$0

Read review →
The scorecard

Score by score

Both retailers run through the same model. Higher is better on every dimension; the forest dot marks the leader on each row.

MetricPet CirclePetstock
Overall score8274
Sample basket$188$205
Pricing8070
Range8478
DeliveryFlat-rate; free over thresholdFrom $8.95; free over threshold
Free shipping over$49$49
Subscription discountAutoship discounts on every orderRepeat order discounts
Price matchNoYes
Private-label transparency7565
Who leads where

The verdict, by category

Cheaper basket

Pet Circle

Standardised sample basket: $188 vs $205.

Better range

Pet Circle

Budget, premium and prescription breadth.

Best subscription

Pet Circle

Autoship and repeat-delivery value.

The trade-offs

Strengths and trade-offs

Pet Circle

What works

  • Deep premium and prescription catalogue
  • Autoship locks in a discount once you commit
  • Fast metro delivery above the free-shipping threshold

Watch-outs

  • Premium positioning means everyday prices often aren't the cheapest per kg on mainstream brands
  • Heavy promotion of own-label Providore and The Nosh Project alongside national brands
  • No physical stores, so no click-and-collect, in-person advice or easy returns
  • Best value is gated behind committing to autoship

Petstock

What works

  • Physical stores with in-house vet services
  • Covers the major premium and prescription brands

Watch-outs

  • Everyday pricing runs high — real value only lands during sales or with loyalty pricing
  • Range and pricing vary by location, so what's online isn't always on the shelf
  • Narrower range and a smaller store network than Petbarn, with nothing it clearly does better
82/ 100
Strong
Editorial assessment

Our verdict

Pet Circle comes out ahead overall on our index (82 vs 74). Pet Circle is cheaper on our sample basket ($188), while the other wins on Pet Circle's range. Pick on what you actually buy — and compare price per kg before you commit.

Not veterinary advice. Prices are illustrative and manually entered for v1 — always confirm live pricing with the retailer before buying.

Frequently asked questions

On our standardised sample basket, Pet Circle is cheaper ($188 vs $205). Prices change often and member or subscription pricing can shift the result — always compare price per kg on the exact product you buy.

Pet Circle scores higher on range (84 vs 78) in our index, covering budget, premium and prescription breadth.

Pet Circle scores higher for subscription value. Pet Circle offers Autoship discounts on every order; Petstock offers Repeat order discounts. Autoship pricing is often where the biggest savings sit.

Pet Circle scores higher on overall value in our index. Value depends on the exact products in your basket, so compare price per kg and subscription pricing on what you actually buy.

No. PetReviews is an independent value and comparison resource, not veterinary advice. Prices are illustrative and manually entered for v1 — always confirm the live price with the retailer before buying.

Read the reviews

Compare value

Related guides