Is Stay Loyal Worth It?
A straight answer on whether Stay Loyal is worth the money — based on its overall score, value score and real cost per serve, with better-value alternatives if it isn't the right fit.
Overall score
0/100
Good
Value score
0/100
Good
From (per day)
$2.30
~15kg dog
Scored by the PetReviews independent review board
Independent scoring · Updated June 2026 · Not veterinary advice
How Stay Loyal scores
Stay Loyal
When Stay Loyal is worth it
- Owners happy to buy online and subscribe
- Dogs suited to grain-free, varied-protein diets
- People who want to see the formulation up front
When to compare carefully
- You want to grab a bag in-store today
- You need wet, prescription or breed-specific diets
Stay Loyal Grain Free Chicken & Fish 20kg
$9.95/kg· $2.30/day
Is Stay Loyal worth it?
A likeable, honest grain-free option that's let down mainly by where you can buy it rather than what's in it. If the direct-order model suits you and you commit to a subscription, the value is fair and the transparency is a real plus. Just go in knowing it's an online buy, not a supermarket grab.
Not veterinary advice. Prices are a guide and can change — always confirm live pricing with the retailer.
Better-value alternatives to Stay Loyal
Premium · Good
A likeable Australian brand that earns its spot for sensitive dogs on the strength of its novel proteins, not marketing. The food is good and the value holds up in the big bags, so the main things to weigh are spottier availability and a price that climbs once you drop to the smaller sizes.
Premium · Good
A competent grain-free all-rounder, but it's mid-pack on every measure and now sits inside a big multi-brand portfolio where recipes have moved with ownership. Fine if the price is right on the day — just don't expect it to out-spec a more focused independent brand.
Premium · Good
Fair value and the rescue donations are real, not greenwash — but the food itself is good rather than exceptional, with mid-premium panels and a narrow range. Buy it because the per-kg value stacks up, not because the cause makes the ingredients better than they are.
Frequently asked questions
Stay Loyal scores 73/100 overall and 71/100 on value in our index (good on value). A likeable, honest grain-free option that's let down mainly by where you can buy it rather than what's in it. If the direct-order model suits you and you commit to a subscription, the value is fair and the transparency is a real plus. Just go in knowing it's an online buy, not a supermarket grab.
For a ~15kg adult dog, Stay Loyal works out from about $2.30 per day on Stay Loyal Grain Free Chicken & Fish 20kg ($9.95/kg). Cost per serve is the figure that matters most — compare it against alternatives before deciding.
If value is your top priority and you're feeding a large dog on a tight budget, compare Stay Loyal carefully against Meals for Mutts and Ivory Coat. The right pick is the one that fits your dog and budget.
Consider Meals for Mutts, Ivory Coat, SavourLife. Compare them on price per kg and cost per day — a different brand may give you more for similar money.
No. PetReviews is an independent value and comparison resource, not veterinary advice. Prices are a guide and can change — always confirm the live price with the retailer before buying.